The Scarlet Letter — symbolism, Puritan setting, and Hawthorne's romance

Nathaniel Hawthorne · 1850

Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter is the foundational American novel about hypocrisy, public shame, and the long psychic life of private sin. Set in seventeenth-century Puritan Boston, it was written two hundred years after the events it describes — a historical novel written by a man whose own ancestor was a judge at the Salem witch trials. Hawthorne knew exactly what kind of culture he was writing about, and his ambivalence toward it shapes every page.

The "romance" genre

Hawthorne distinguished, in his prefaces, between the novel and the romance. A novel was an attempt at probable representation of ordinary life. A romance, as he defined it, was free to introduce a "latitude" of the marvelous and the symbolic — to use the realistic surface as a vehicle for moral and psychological investigation that strict realism could not deliver. The Scarlet Letter is announced as a romance, and the announcement matters: the novel's coincidences, its hyper-symbolic A, its supernatural elements, all sit comfortably inside the form Hawthorne names.

The A as multivalent symbol

The scarlet letter A pinned to Hester's chest is the most analyzed symbol in American literature. Critically, what makes it interesting is its shift. It does not mean one thing:

Adultery — the original meaning the community has assigned.
Able — the meaning Hester earns through her years of dignified labour and care for the sick.
Angel — appearing in the sky over the Governor's deathbed, possibly imagined by the community.
Art — Hester's elaborate embroidery of the letter (sealed with gold thread) transforms it from punishment into work.
And finally, America — Hester's identity as a Puritan exile in the New World, the symbol the colony has put on her chest becoming her identity-marker in a way the community did not intend.

Hawthorne never fixes the meaning. The novel's argument is that symbols change as the communities reading them change.

The four central characters

Hester Prynne — the wearer of the letter. The novel's moral centre. Her dignity, her labour, her refusal to name Dimmesdale all shape the story.
Pearl — Hester's daughter, named for the "pearl of great price." Wild, mercurial, symbol-attentive in a way the adults are not. She is the novel's living scarlet letter.
Reverend Dimmesdale — Hester's lover and Pearl's father. Holds the community's most prestigious pulpit. His failure to confess is the novel's central moral question.
Roger Chillingworth — Hester's husband, thought lost, who arrives to find his wife on the scaffold. Becomes the novel's foil: where Dimmesdale is destroyed by his sin's concealment, Chillingworth is destroyed by his pursuit of revenge.

The novel's deepest argument: the public sin (Hester's) heals through public confession; the private sins (Dimmesdale's concealment, Chillingworth's vengeance) destroy their bearers.

The Puritan setting

Hawthorne uses the Puritan setting both historically and emblematically. Historically, he is precise: the laws, the sermon culture, the relationship of clergy and magistracy, the typology of sin. Emblematically, he is using Puritanism as a laboratory for studying what happens when a community organises itself around the visible marking of moral transgression — a question that, written in 1850 in mid-century America, was not just historical.

The scaffold scenes

The novel's structure pivots on three scaffold scenes:

Chapter 2 — Hester on the scaffold with Pearl, exposed to public shame.
Chapter 12 — Dimmesdale, alone at midnight, attempting a private penance no one witnesses. The meteor A blazes in the sky overhead.
Chapter 23 — Dimmesdale's final confession on the scaffold, with Hester and Pearl, followed immediately by his death.

The geographical repetition is the novel's formal spine. Each scaffold scene reframes the original one. The novel's final movement makes the private scene (midnight) public (midday), and the secret sinner finally joins the public one. The structure is the argument.

The narrator's introduction

The novel opens not with the story but with a long autobiographical sketch ("The Custom-House") in which Hawthorne describes finding the manuscript of The Scarlet Letter in the attic of the Salem Custom House where he worked. The device is a frame narrative borrowing from the eighteenth-century novel's tradition of "discovered manuscripts." It distances Hawthorne from authorship, locates the story in a real Massachusetts geography, and gives him permission to call what follows a romance. Most modern editions reprint "The Custom-House" with the novel; read it before the story to see how the frame is doing its work.

Themes worth tracking

Public vs. private sin. The novel's central question, structured by the scaffold scenes.
The community's complicity. Hester is shamed for an offence the entire community has secretly participated in (the gossiping crowds, Chillingworth's vengeance, Dimmesdale's silence). The novel asks who is really being judged.
Nature vs. settlement. The forest is where the lovers can speak truth; the town is where they cannot. The novel's geographical morality is consistent and ancient.
The labour of meaning. Hester reshapes the A's meaning through years of work. The novel argues that public meanings can be rewritten by individual practice, slowly, over time.

Try Lexio

Look up any word like this — in any book, in any browser.

Lexio is a free Chrome extension and web app that reads a word's actual context and tells you what it means in this sentence, not from a generic dictionary.

Try Lexio — free →