Slaughterhouse-Five — time, trauma, and Vonnegut's postmodern form

Kurt Vonnegut · 1969

Kurt Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse-Five is the canonical postmodern American novel — formally innovative, relentlessly self-aware, built around the central historical event of its author's life: the Allied firebombing of Dresden in February 1945, which Vonnegut survived as a prisoner of war. To read the novel well is to follow how Vonnegut uses postmodern devices to handle a subject he confesses, in the first chapter, he could not write directly.

The structure: time-unstuck

The novel's central formal innovation is the protagonist's condition: Billy Pilgrim is "unstuck in time." He moves — involuntarily, without warning — between moments of his life: his childhood, his time as a soldier, the Dresden bombing, his marriage, his abduction by aliens, his death, and the moments after his death. The narrative jumps with him, often mid-paragraph.

This is technically a sustained form of prolepsis-and- analepsis raised to a structural principle. But Vonnegut is doing more than rearranging chronology. The technique is a literary representation of how traumatic memory works — the past arrives unbidden, the survivor is yanked back into it without choosing, the temporal sequence the conscious mind tries to maintain is constantly broken by the past re-asserting itself.

The first chapter

The novel opens with a remarkable chapter in which Vonnegut breaks the fourth wall: he addresses the reader directly, explains that this is a book about the Dresden bombing he survived, describes his struggle to write it, lists what he has tried, admits that the book that follows is "short and jumbled and jangled, because there is nothing intelligent to say about a massacre." The novel's main narrative — Billy Pilgrim's story — begins only after Vonnegut has confessed that direct narration of the event is impossible.

The first chapter is itself a piece of metafiction. Vonnegut is arguing that the conventional novel form cannot hold what he saw in Dresden, and the strange form that follows is what's left when conventional narration fails.

The Tralfamadorians

The aliens who abduct Billy — the Tralfamadorians — are the novel's most disputed feature. They see all of time at once; for them, there is no sequence, no birth or death, just the eternal moment of every moment co-existing. Their attitude toward death: "So it goes." Bad moments exist; good moments also exist; both forever; nothing is undone.

How to read the Tralfamadorians is the novel's central interpretive question. Two main readings:

Philosophical. Vonnegut is offering the Tralfamadorian perspective as a serious alternative to Western linear time — a way of accepting the unchangeability of past events without despair.
Symptomatic. The Tralfamadorians are Billy's traumatic coping mechanism — a fantasy of being able to step outside the linear time in which Dresden keeps happening. Vonnegut is showing PTSD, not endorsing its metaphysics.

The novel does not settle the question, which is what makes it a serious book rather than a science-fiction novel about benevolent aliens.

"So it goes"

The novel's most famous phrase. After every reported death — and the novel reports hundreds — the narrator says "So it goes." Three words; the same three words; over a hundred times.

The phrase has been read as:

Resigned Tralfamadorian acceptance.
Black humour — making the relentlessness of death conspicuous through repetition.
An anti-rhetorical refusal of conventional grief language — Vonnegut declining to elevate any death with the kind of literary attention that would dignify it and so partially conceal what death is.

The phrase's flatness is doing work that elaborate prose about mortality couldn't. The novel's deepest move is in this small refrain.

The Dresden bombing

The novel's central event — the firebombing of Dresden on 13–15 February 1945 — killed somewhere between 25,000 and 35,000 people, mostly civilians, in what was at the time considered a city of no significant military value. Vonnegut was a 22-year-old American prisoner of war held in a meat-packing plant called Schlachthof-Fünf ("Slaughterhouse-Five") which gave him shelter from the bombing and from which he was put to work, the morning after, digging bodies out of the rubble.

The novel never directly describes the bombing. The whole book is the working-out of how to write about an experience the writer cannot describe. The strange form is the answer.

The recurring quotations

Several phrases recur throughout the novel, each time slightly differently weighted:

"So it goes." After every death.
"Billy is unstuck in time." The narrator's framing of the protagonist's condition.
"And so on." A second flat-affect refrain.
The Serenity Prayer — "God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change…" — hangs on Billy's office wall and is quoted near the novel's end. The prayer is given as the closest thing the novel has to a moral position.

The anti-war argument

Vonnegut's argument is not made through speeches; it is made through form. The structure refuses to give the war's violence the conventional dignified narration that lets readers process violence comfortably. The repetition of "So it goes" refuses to elevate any one death. The aliens' indifference refuses the consolation of historical meaning. The novel's deepest claim is that the war's violence cannot be put into a story that doesn't, in some way, dignify the violence by giving it shape.

Themes worth tracking

Trauma and narrative form. The novel is the great American literary example of how trauma resists conventional storytelling.
The unbearable past. Billy keeps being pulled back to Dresden. The novel argues that survivors do not "process" the past; the past keeps repeating.
Free will as illusion. The Tralfamadorian view denies the conventional Western understanding of choice. The novel's relationship to this denial is its own deepest tension.
Black humour as endurance. The novel's refusal of solemnity in the face of mass death is itself the form of moral seriousness Vonnegut has decided is possible.

Try Lexio

Look up any word like this — in any book, in any browser.

Lexio is a free Chrome extension and web app that reads a word's actual context and tells you what it means in this sentence, not from a generic dictionary.

Try Lexio — free →