Jane Eyre — voice, Gothic conventions, and the female bildungsroman

Charlotte Brontë · 1847

Charlotte Brontë's Jane Eyre is the foundational female bildungsroman in English. Published the same year as her sister Emily's Wuthering Heights (1847), the novel inaugurated several enduring forms — the first-person female narrator with a distinct moral voice, the Gothic mansion as psychological landscape, the small heroine whose interiority is the novel's argument. Generations of subsequent fiction owe more to Jane Eyre than to almost any other Victorian novel.

The first-person voice

The novel's signature achievement is its first-person narration. Jane addresses the reader directly ("Reader, I married him"), interrupts herself, justifies her choices, reveals her doubts. The voice is at once confidential and self-controlled. It is the voice of a woman who has been told all her life she has no right to speak, and who speaks anyway.

Brontë's structural innovation was making this voice carry an entire novel. Before Jane Eyre, women in fiction were usually objects of male-narrated interest; here, a woman holds the narrative and the moral authority for five hundred pages. The novel's influence is partly the influence of that formal choice.

The bildungsroman structure

The novel is built as a five-stage bildungsroman, each stage set in a different location:

Gateshead — Jane's childhood with the Reeds, her cruel cousin John, the red-room episode. The novel's first Gothic image: a small girl locked in a haunted room.
Lowood School — Jane's brutal education under Mr. Brocklehurst, the friendship with Helen Burns, the typhus outbreak that establishes the institution's hypocrisy.
Thornfield — Jane as governess to Rochester's ward; the novel's central romantic and Gothic drama; Bertha Mason in the attic; the aborted wedding.
Moor House — Jane in flight, sheltered by St. John Rivers and his sisters; the inheritance revelation; St. John's marriage proposal.
Ferndean — Jane's return to a blinded, humbled Rochester; the marriage that closes the novel.

Each stage strips away a layer of dependency or false authority. The bildungsroman's classical pattern — formation through trial — is followed precisely.

The Gothic in Jane Eyre

The novel borrows the Gothic conventions — the imposing house with a hidden room, the laughter in the night, the madwoman in the attic, the storm at the moment of emotional crisis — but transforms them. Where Gothic novels usually treat the supernatural and the female protagonist's fear as their primary horror, Brontë makes the Gothic psychological. The threats in Thornfield are real, but Jane's fear is anatomized in detail; we see her thinking through it, not just feeling it.

Bertha Mason: the long debate

Bertha Mason, Rochester's first wife confined in the Thornfield attic, has been the subject of one of the longest running arguments in literary criticism. Different readings:

Madwoman in the attic — Gilbert and Gubar's famous 1979 reading saw Bertha as Jane's doppelgänger, expressing the rage Jane cannot voice. Bertha burns the marriage bed; Jane wants to.
Colonial unconscious — Jean Rhys's novel Wide Sargasso Sea (1966) retells the story from Bertha's perspective as a Creole woman from Jamaica. Rhys's reading: Bertha is the colonial figure the English novel cannot represent except as horror.
Plot device — older readings simply took Bertha as the obstacle to Jane's happiness, narrated in the conventions of the period's racism and psychopathologization.

The novel itself is uncomfortable with Bertha — the descriptions of her use racialized and dehumanizing language that modern readers can't ignore. Reading the novel honestly means holding both its formal achievement and its colonial investments together.

Rochester as Byronic hero

Rochester is the Byronic hero in late form: brooding, secretive, scarred by a past he won't discuss, contemptuous of convention, possessed of a wild charisma. Brontë's modification: she puts him through real consequences. He cannot marry Jane while Bertha lives; his deception, when revealed, costs him her; the fire in which he tries to save Bertha blinds and maims him. By the novel's end, he is humbled in ways most Byronic heroes are not. The marriage that closes the novel is, in Jane's words, between equals — because Rochester has had his power literally taken from him.

Religion and the rejection of St. John Rivers

St. John Rivers, Jane's cousin and missionary suitor, is the novel's representative of self-denying Protestant religion. His proposal is not romantic; he wants Jane as a missionary helpmeet, useful for her competence rather than loved for herself. Jane's refusal is one of the novel's quiet feminist moments. "If I were to marry you, you would kill me. You are killing me now." The line refuses the Victorian assumption that a woman should welcome any reasonable marriage offer; Jane demands something more.

Themes worth tracking

Independence as moral foundation. Jane refuses to be Rochester's mistress, refuses St. John's marriage of convenience, returns to Rochester only when she is independently wealthy. The novel's argument is that love is only possible between equals — and that equality cannot be claimed; it must be earned.
Voice and being heard. Almost every stage of Jane's life is about her right to speak. The novel ends with her marrying a man who has been blinded and so must listen.
The body and the soul. Brontë was a clergyman's daughter, and the novel's religious framework is serious. Jane's choices are repeatedly framed in terms of what her soul will survive.
Class and confined possibility. Jane is a governess — a marginal class position, neither servant nor family. The novel's deepest social work is its sympathy for this class of women.

Try Lexio

Look up any word like this — in any book, in any browser.

Lexio is a free Chrome extension and web app that reads a word's actual context and tells you what it means in this sentence, not from a generic dictionary.

Try Lexio — free →