What "the uncanny" means in literature

A term you'll meet in Freud and literary theory.

The uncanny is one of those critical terms that gets used as a fancy synonym for "creepy." Its actual literary and psychoanalytic meaning is more specific, and the specificity is what makes it useful. The uncanny is the feeling of the familiar made strange — and that has a structure.

Freud's essay

The English term translates the German unheimlich, which literally means "unhomely." Freud opens his 1919 essay "Das Unheimliche" by noticing the etymology: heimlich means homely, familiar, intimate — and yet by another sense it also means secret, concealed, hidden away. Unheimlich is its negation: unhomely, unfamiliar — but also, paradoxically, that which should have remained hidden and has come into the open.

Freud's claim: the uncanny is not produced by the simply unknown. It is produced when something familiar — something repressed, forgotten, or once intimately known — returns in an unfamiliar form. The shock is recognition more than discovery.

The classic triggers

Freud catalogues situations that reliably produce the uncanny:

Doubles, twins, doppelgängers. One's own face on a stranger.
Automata that seem alive — dolls, mannequins, waxworks, robots.
The dead seeming to return — ghosts, revenants, mistaken identity.
Severed body parts behaving as if independent.
Coincidences that seem fated. The same number appearing in unrelated contexts, the same stranger glimpsed twice.
Returning to a place that is not where you thought. Getting lost in a familiar city. Finding a room that should not exist in your own house.

The common feature is the disturbance of a boundary you had assumed was stable: living/dead, self/other, animate/inanimate, here/there.

The uncanny in literature

E.T.A. Hoffmann, "The Sandman." Freud builds his essay around this story, in which a young man falls in love with what turns out to be a mechanical doll.
Poe, "The Fall of the House of Usher" and "William Wilson." The double; the house that is also a body.
Henry James, "The Turn of the Screw." Are the ghosts real or are they the governess's projections? The indeterminacy is itself uncanny.
Kafka, "The Metamorphosis." The familiar domestic morning ruined by the impossible body.
Shirley Jackson, The Haunting of Hill House. The house that knows the protagonist's history better than she does.

The uncanny in modern criticism

The term has expanded beyond Freud. Critics talk about the "uncanny valley" in robotics, the "postcolonial uncanny" (the homeland that has become unhomely), the "uncanny" of digital images of faces. The common thread is always: a boundary you took for granted has shifted, and what you thought was familiar shows you it was never simple.

How to read it

When a critic invokes the uncanny, do not read it as a stronger "spooky." Read it as a structural claim: something the text treats as familiar contains, inside it, the strange. Ask what boundary the text is troubling. Is it living/dead? Self/other? Public/private? The disturbance of that specific boundary is what the text is doing. The atmosphere of unease is the symptom; the boundary violation is the cause.

Try Lexio

Look up any word like this — in any book, in any browser.

Lexio is a free Chrome extension and web app that reads a word's actual context and tells you what it means in this sentence, not from a generic dictionary.

Try Lexio — free →