Simile vs. metaphor — the difference

A term you'll meet in figurative language.

Both similes and metaphors work by comparing one thing to another. The difference is in how explicit the comparison is — and that small difference matters more than it sounds, because it changes the relationship between the two terms and the kind of cognitive work the figure does.

The basic definitions

A simile declares a comparison openly, usually with "like" or "as." "My love is like a red, red rose." The comparison is announced; the reader is invited to compare two things and notice the resemblance.

A metaphor asserts identity rather than comparison. "My love is a red, red rose." The figure collapses the gap between the two terms. The lover doesn't resemble a rose; she is one, in some essential sense the metaphor asks us to feel.

Why the distinction matters

The shift from "like" to "is" looks small but transforms the effect:

Similes preserve distance. The two terms remain separate; the comparison is acknowledged as a comparison. This makes similes more cognitively transparent and often more analytical — the reader can examine the resemblance.
Metaphors fuse. By dropping "like," the metaphor demands a different kind of acceptance: the reader must, momentarily, treat the two things as one. This generates more imaginative pressure and often more emotional intensity, but at some cognitive cost — metaphors can be harder to parse.

Examples

Simile:

"O my Luve is like a red, red rose" — Robert Burns
"The fog comes / on little cat feet" — actually metaphor; a simile version would be "like little cat feet"
"Life is like a box of chocolates" — Forrest Gump

Metaphor:

"All the world's a stage" — Shakespeare
"The fog comes / on little cat feet" — Carl Sandburg
"Hope is the thing with feathers" — Emily Dickinson

Extended metaphors and conceits

A metaphor that is sustained for several lines or an entire work is called an extended metaphor. When the extension is especially elaborate, intellectually demanding, and spans a whole poem, it is called a conceit. John Donne's famous comparison of two lovers' souls to a pair of compasses in "A Valediction: Forbidding Mourning" is the classic example. The conceit is metaphysical poetry's signature move.

Dead metaphors

Many of the metaphors in everyday language have been used so often that their figurative nature has worn off — "the foot of the mountain," "running for office," "falling in love." These are called dead metaphors. They started as striking comparisons but have hardened into ordinary vocabulary. Watching how recent these have become is a reminder of how much of ordinary thought is fossilized poetry.

The simple test

If "like" or "as" is there explicitly: simile. If the comparison is asserted as identity: metaphor. Beyond that test, ask what the figure is doing: opening a careful comparison, or collapsing two things into one for emotional or imaginative force? That's where the analytical work begins.

Try Lexio

Look up any word like this — in any book, in any browser.

Lexio is a free Chrome extension and web app that reads a word's actual context and tells you what it means in this sentence, not from a generic dictionary.

Try Lexio — free →