What a red herring is

A term you'll meet in mystery, narrative, and rhetoric.

A red herring is a clue or detail deliberately planted to lead the audience (or an opponent) toward the wrong conclusion. In a mystery, it's the suspicious character who turns out to be innocent; in an argument, it's the irrelevant point dragged in to change the subject.

Where the phrase comes from

A "red herring" is a strong-smelling smoked fish. The popular story — that the scent was used to throw hunting dogs off a trail — is itself probably a bit of folklore, but the metaphor stuck: a red herring is anything pungent enough to distract you from the real scent.

In detective fiction

The red herring is the lifeblood of the whodunit. Agatha Christie was its master: a dropped glove, a quarrel overheard, a too-obvious suspect — each one engineered to send you down the wrong path so the real solution lands as a shock. A good red herring must be plausible enough to convince and fair enough that, in hindsight, you could have known better.

Red herring vs. Chekhov's gun

The two are opposites. Chekhov's gun is a detail that looks unimportant but pays off later; a red herring looks important but pays off as nothing. One rewards your attention; the other punishes it — on purpose.

The logical fallacy

Outside fiction, "red herring" names a fallacy: introducing an irrelevant issue to divert an argument. ("We can't worry about the budget when there are bigger problems in the world.") Spotting red herrings — in stories and in debate — is the same skill: noticing when your attention is being steered away from what actually matters.

Try Lexio

Look up any word like this — in any book, in any browser.

Lexio is a free Chrome extension and web app that reads a word's actual context and tells you what it means in this sentence, not from a generic dictionary.

Try Lexio — free →